Who Did Taylor Frankie Paul Swing With – MomTok Scandal Facts

Taylor Frankie Paul, a prominent MomTok Mormon influencer, revealed in 2022 that she participated in “soft swinging” with a group of couples connected to the TikTok parenting community. The admission triggered a public scandal, ended her marriage to Tate Paul, and became the subject of the Hulu docuseries The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Central to the controversy was her confession about kissing another man outside the arrangement, which she shared with her then-husband.

The scandal fractured friendships within the tight-knit MomTok circle and sparked conflicting accounts about the extent of activities that took place. While Paul described group encounters involving multiple couples, some participants disputed her version of events. The fallout extended beyond the initial disclosure, with legal involvement and ongoing relationship drama making headlines in subsequent years.

Understanding who Paul connected with during this period requires separating confirmed statements from disputed claims and unresolved questions about the full scope of involvement.

Who Did Taylor Frankie Paul Swing With?

Taylor Frankie Paul admitted to participating in soft swinging with at least four couples from the MomTok community. The arrangement involved non-penetrative group intimacy conducted while spouses were present, though participants later offered conflicting descriptions of what actually occurred.

Key Insights

• Taylor Frankie Paul confirmed kissing Brayden Rowley, a married man, which she disclosed directly to her then-husband Tate Paul
• The couple Miranda and Chase McWhorter were central figures in the swinging arrangement, with Chase later developing romantic feelings for Taylor
• Taylor described activities including group encounters in showers and same beds, with husbands sometimes filming the interactions
• Miranda McWhorter disputed these accounts, insisting involvement was limited to spin-the-bottle games and kissing without intercourse
• The scandal became public after Taylor posted on TikTok that “no one is innocent” and “everyone has hooked up with everyone”
• At least four couples participated in the broader group, though identities of all participants remain partially unclear
• Taylor’s confession about Brayden Rowley directly preceded her divorce from Tate Paul

Who Is Brayden Rowley in the Scandal?

Brayden Rowley was one of the husbands involved in the MomTok soft swinging circle. He was married to McKenna Gibbons at the time of the activities. Taylor Frankie Paul confessed to kissing Brayden Rowley, an act she disclosed directly to her then-husband Tate Paul, which ultimately contributed to the escalation of the scandal.

According to available accounts, Taylor met Brayden at a cabin party that she initially believed would be an innocent gathering. She later discovered the event was connected to swinging activities. The kiss between Taylor and Brayden represented a departure from the established boundaries of the arrangement, as it occurred without Tate’s direct participation or knowledge at the time.

Brayden’s Ex-Wife McKenna Gibbons

McKenna Gibbons was Brayden Rowley’s wife during the period of the MomTok scandal. She was part of the broader TikTok Mormon mom influencer community, though sources do not detail her direct participation in swinging activities. The scandal fractured the MomTok group, with members dividing in their loyalties.

Following the scandal’s public emergence, Brayden and McKenna’s marriage ended in divorce. Mayci Neeley, another MomTok figure, later recounted that the fallout divided friends, with some turning against Taylor weeks after the initial disclosure.

What Is Known About Taylor Frankie Paul and Miranda?

Miranda McWhorter was Taylor Frankie Paul’s closest friend before the scandal. Both women participated in soft swinging activities with their respective spouses, and their friendship became central to the controversy when accounts of what occurred diverged dramatically.

Taylor described specific encounters involving both women, including a night when four wives wore short shorts and made out together while husbands filmed. She described the atmosphere as intoxicated and detailed activities that went beyond kissing.

Miranda disputed these characterizations, stating she would “go to her grave” maintaining that involvement never extended beyond spin-the-bottle and kissing. She described feeling “weird” about the activities, stopped participating, and initially denied involvement publicly when questioned.

The friendship deteriorated following the scandal’s exposure. People.com reported in May 2025 on the current state of their relationship, noting the complicated aftermath of their shared experience and subsequent public fallout.

Did Taylor Frankie Paul Develop Feelings for Someone Specific?

Chase McWhorter, Miranda’s then-husband, developed romantic feelings for Taylor Frankie Paul during the period of the soft swinging arrangement. The confession came after Taylor shared a sex dream she had about Chase with the group.

Taylor apologized to Miranda after revealing the dream, but did not immediately inform her about Chase’s resulting feelings. Tate Paul later confirmed to Miranda that Chase had expressed romantic interest in Taylor. Taylor maintained she did not “steal” Chase from Miranda, denying any reciprocal romantic involvement.

Chase denied ever having sexual intercourse with Taylor, stating on record that when questioned about whether he had “fucked” Taylor, the answer was “no.” He acknowledged the emotional connection but maintained physical boundaries.

Following the divorce from Miranda, Chase remained connected to the group dynamics that continued to unfold publicly. His feelings for Taylor represented a turning point in the group’s cohesion, as the emotional entanglement complicated what had initially been framed as a purely physical arrangement.

Timeline of the MomTok Swinging Scandal

The events unfolded over several years, with the public revelation in 2022 representing merely the culmination of months of escalating involvement and interpersonal complications within the group.

1. Formation of swinging group: Taylor and Tate Paul began soft swinging with Miranda and Chase McWhorter, along with at least two other couples from the MomTok community.
2. Escalation of activities: Group encounters intensified, including filming and intimate interactions, though participants disagree on the extent of physical contact.
3. Chase’s feelings emerge: After Taylor shared a sex dream about Chase, he confessed romantic feelings for her. Taylor apologized to Miranda but did not immediately reveal Chase’s confession.
4. The Brayden confession: Taylor told Tate about kissing Brayden Rowley. Tate, already aware of the Chase situation, called Miranda to confirm the details.
5. Scandal goes viral: Taylor posted on TikTok in 2022: “No one is innocent. Everyone has hooked up with everyone,” sparking widespread discussion.
6. Divorce and fallout: Taylor divorced Tate Paul. The group divided, with some friends supporting Taylor and others distancing themselves.
7. SLOMW documentary (2024): Hulu released The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, documenting the fallout. The Mormon church criticized the series as a “gross misrepresentation” of the faith.
8. Current developments (2025): Taylor promotes the series and her Bachelorette appearance while facing domestic violence allegations involving her new boyfriend Dakota Mortensen.

What Is Confirmed Versus What Remains Unclear

The Context of MomTok and Soft Swinging

MomTok refers to the TikTok community of Mormon mothers who share content related to parenting, faith, and lifestyle. The community gained significant attention in the early 2020s for its large following and influence within the influencer ecosystem.

The concept of “soft swinging” as described by participants involves intimate activities between group members while all spouses remain present, but stops short of full partner exchange. This distinction became central to the dispute, with Taylor’s descriptions suggesting boundaries were crossed while Miranda maintained the arrangement stayed within agreed-upon limits.

The scandal’s public emergence through social media reflected the tensions between the influencers’ public personas as traditional Mormon wives and the private activities that came to light. The subsequent Hulu docuseries sought to tell the story from the participants’ perspectives, though official church representatives criticized the portrayal.

Sources and Statements

“Did you ask Taylor if I ever fucked her? The answer is no.”

— Chase McWhorter, responding to questions about his relationship with Taylor Frankie Paul

“I would go to my grave [saying] we never hooked up. It was literally just spin the bottle and kissing.”

— Miranda McWhorter, disputing Taylor’s account of events

Taylor Frankie Paul has spoken publicly about her involvement through interviews and her participation in The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives. Miranda McWhorter has maintained her disputed version through separate interviews. Chase McWhorter denied sexual contact while acknowledging emotional involvement. The conflicting accounts remain largely unresolved in public statements.

Summary

Taylor Frankie Paul confirmed swinging with at least four couples from the MomTok community, with the scandal becoming public through her confession about kissing Brayden Rowley. Central figures included her then-husband Tate Paul, close friend Miranda McWhorter and her husband Chase McWhorter, and Brayden Rowley with his then-wife McKenna Gibbons. Conflicting accounts exist regarding the extent of activities, with Miranda disputing Taylor’s more detailed descriptions. Chase McWhorter developed romantic feelings for Taylor, complicating the group’s dynamics. Both marriages ended in divorce following the 2022 disclosure. The controversy was documented in Hulu’s The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, and Taylor continues to face public scrutiny while pursuing new ventures including her Bachelorette appearance.

For additional context on related influencer controversies, see our analysis of Doug Christie Chris Webber Paternity Rumor Facts and Max Fried Rose Lavelle Dating Rumors Explained.

Frequently Asked Questions